Author Topic: Reading recommendations  (Read 61197 times)

Online Rasa

  • Section Commander
  • 1 Section
  • DISSIPEL
Re: Reading recommendations
« Reply #165 on: August 07, 2018, 12:16:55 PM »
A McDonalds prize lottery scam that got forgotten because of certain events in september 2001: https://www.thedailybeast.com/how-an-ex-cop-rigged-mcdonalds-monopoly-game-and-stole-millions

Offline CharlesZulu

  • 1 Section
  • The reluctant jimpy
Re: Reading recommendations
« Reply #166 on: August 16, 2018, 03:43:04 PM »
SAPKOWSKI Andrzej. (1992-2013) ['The Witcher Series']. "The Last wish", "Sword of Destiny", "Blood of Elves [1]", "Time of Contempt [2]", "Baptism of Fire [3]", "The Tower of the Swallow [4]", "The Lady of the Lake [5]" I have also not yet read "Season of Storms". Gollancz - English Translation [Kindle editions]

The Witcher - Many of us have played the game, some (cough) obsessively, but what about the books? Is the source material up to scratch?

Well the very good news is the original works by Sapkowski are definitely worth a read, with engaging stories and characters (some we already know, or rather think we already know) and with a three-way (oooer) personal 'human' family story intertwined within a massive epic fantasy; all delivered with intelligence, skill and not a little humour and which in many ways manages to be more grounded (magic and monsters aside) than the game.

Even more than the game there is also real ambiguity in the stories, (almost) nobody is wholly good or evil and the choices the many characters make are not clear cut. Well intentioned actions have terrible repercussions... this isn't goody-goody elves, noble-paladins, conquer-the-universe-baddies and happy-ever-afters. It's grey, gritty and nothing and no-one is safe or even all that wholesome, and it's all the better for it.

The books aren't perfect, although I suspect the translation from the original Polish is an issue as English idioms and phrasing are occasionally clumsy. Not actually a flaw, more a design choice, but the chronology of the series is also erratic (especially in the main novels) with the text darting constantly between many characters and varied situations; these not always seemingly connected and often not continuing again until much, much later - even into the next books. Sapkowski frequently (over) uses his signature trick of jumping through time (and space) in successive paragraphs which can be rather disorientating until the rhythm becomes more familiar.

The chapters, or more accurately paragraphs in each chapter, also switch constantly in tone: with political exposition (thankfully sparing as these are mostly drudgery), discourses on philosophy and beliefs, mills and boon class erotica, short tales with a twist, and littered throughout lovingly described monsters, encounters and above all fight sequences both small and large e.g. an epic unfolding description of a major battle near the end of the series is quite simply narrative mastery. Character development arcs are also marked, realistic and interesting although as hinted the dialogue is less assured, sometimes it is subtle and often it is downright clever and funny but at other times conversations are jarring or downright cheesy.

Initially I found it a trial keeping track over how all the newly introduced themes and characters fit into the main storyline, which is still (you may be relieved?) anchored around the game's main interlinked tales of Geralt, Yennifer and Ciri. It's a clear testament to the richness of the book world and the author's incredibly cunning plot structure that most of these thematic strands are memorable in their own right and also make sense when they finally climax (ooer #2) and directly affect the main trio - often these payoffs also come with very generous helpings of 'ahhh that's clever'.

To summarise then - something excellent has come out of Poland (apart from 303 Sqn) and I can heartily recommend you again set aside the time to travel to the Northern Realms. It's a bumpy and often a very surprising ride, the story is different to the game in many details, though not theme, and the books are definitely a cut above most trite fantasy writing. The fact that these same works enrich and surpass (and yes at times overwrite) the necessary story limitations within the game version just adds to the fun. Damn it all, Sapkowski even made me want to play the whole bloody game AGAIN (even though at the time of writing I still haven't quite finished the second DLC).

Final advice: The actual reading sequence can be a bit obscure, therefore I suggest you read the two short story collections first ("Last wish" then "Sword of Destiny") before starting on the main series proper as numbered above. NB I haven't yet read "Season of Storms" but this is a fairly recent standalone work that chronologically slots -apparently without impact- into the main book series.

[Update: I have now read 'SoS' and it does indeed slot neatly into the main timeline with no adverse impact, a rather cunning multi-layered tale which even throws a bit more light on 'witcher' lore and Geralt's personality. It would be nice to think Sapkowski still has a few more of these books up his sleeve that he will publish in due course.]


"Youth could win, but had not learned to keep: and was pitiably weak against age." - T.E. Lawrence

Offline woodsy

  • Ex Members
Re: Reading recommendations
« Reply #167 on: August 18, 2018, 10:56:33 AM »
I've just finished a book called the devil's guard by George elford and its a very graphic book about the SS French foreign legion battalion fighting the Viet mien highly recommend if you enjoy torture, brutal murder and something about Germans

Offline Anthony

  • Fondles Civilians
  • 1 Section
Re: Reading recommendations
« Reply #168 on: September 06, 2018, 08:58:42 AM »
How do you stop Big Orange from enacting something stupid?

Simple, you just take the paper away from him.

Custom signature courtesy of Ben Irelandicus

"Tonight at 11: Teens are having sex younger and younger. Wanna watch?"

Online Rasa

  • Section Commander
  • 1 Section
  • DISSIPEL
Re: Reading recommendations
« Reply #169 on: November 22, 2018, 02:15:17 PM »

 

chap